From today's Seattle Times
Sep. 9th, 2007 08:41 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
thoreauSept. 11 was a shock — much like the state of the world today
By Leonard Pitts Jr.
Sept. 11 falls on a Tuesday this year. It will be the first time since that other Sept. 11, six years ago.
Do you remember? Can you recall how difficult it was to even conceive of going forward from that moment? The events of that day had so thoroughly lacerated us that it seemed as if, in some small corner of our collective soul, the clock had stopped. In that corner, it would forever be 8:46 EDT on the morning of Sept. 11, 2001.
Do you remember? If so, then the world as it stands six years later must come as something of a shock.
Six years ago, we saw people rushing to the World Trade Center site to search for survivors and recover bodies. Heroes, we said. Six years later, largely removed from public attention, many of those same heroes are sick and even dying, poisoned by the soot and dirt they breathed.
Six years ago, appalled and infuriated, the world rallied to our side. Candles and cards were left at our embassies. The French newspaper Le Monde declared "We Are All Americans Now." The Masai, a tribe in rural Kenya, sent us 14 cows, a gift regarded by their culture as sacred. Six years later, angry demonstrators trail our president wherever he travels, and it is headline news when he is actually cheered in Albania.
Six years ago, we vowed revenge on Osama bin Laden, the wealthy Saudi who masterminded the attacks. We would bring him in, said the president, "dead or alive." Six years later, bin Laden is still free, and the president has said he is not particularly concerned about that.
Do you remember?
The terrorist attacks of six years ago this week are sometimes compared to the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor 66 years ago this Dec. 7. That is, of course, a reference to the shock, disbelief and anger Americans of both eras felt.
But there is a telling difference between 12/7 and 9/11. From the 1941 attack, there was forged a sense of national mission and purpose. Feelings of shock, disbelief and anger became the building blocks of a consensus that we would do whatever, spend whatever and sacrifice whatever until victory was won. After the 2001 attacks, by contrast, we talked national mission and purpose, but it soon became apparent that it was only talk.
Those feelings of shock, disbelief and anger became instead the building blocks of a political machine that duped the nation into a war of choice that had nothing to do with the terrorist attacks, eroded American civil liberties under the guise of protecting American lives and branded as traitors those who said, "Hey, wait a minute."
Worst of all, it squandered the moment, threw away a historic chance to build a national — and international — consensus that could have marginalized the architects of terror, maybe even reshaped the world, more effectively than all the bombs and bullets used to date in Iraq.
This anniversary, then, laments not simply the loss of life, but of opportunity. And perhaps the worst thing is, one senses most Americans are like their president: We don't think about bin Laden that much these days. He is not front-of-mind anymore.
So it is worth pausing here to remember that just six years ago, we were attacked.
Six years ago, people leaped from flaming skyscrapers.
Six years ago, skyscrapers fell.
Six years ago, an airplane tore a hole in the Pentagon.
Six years ago, a hijacked plane crashed.
Six years ago, searing, airless shock was followed by resolve. Clear, cold, iron-fisted resolve.
Six years later, the shock is gone and it seems like the resolve is, too.
Do we remember? You couldn't prove it by me.
Miami Herald columnist Leonard Pitts Jr.'s column appears regularly on editorial pages of The Times. His e-mail address is: lpitts@herald.com
By Leonard Pitts Jr.
Sept. 11 falls on a Tuesday this year. It will be the first time since that other Sept. 11, six years ago.
Do you remember? Can you recall how difficult it was to even conceive of going forward from that moment? The events of that day had so thoroughly lacerated us that it seemed as if, in some small corner of our collective soul, the clock had stopped. In that corner, it would forever be 8:46 EDT on the morning of Sept. 11, 2001.
Do you remember? If so, then the world as it stands six years later must come as something of a shock.
Six years ago, we saw people rushing to the World Trade Center site to search for survivors and recover bodies. Heroes, we said. Six years later, largely removed from public attention, many of those same heroes are sick and even dying, poisoned by the soot and dirt they breathed.
Six years ago, appalled and infuriated, the world rallied to our side. Candles and cards were left at our embassies. The French newspaper Le Monde declared "We Are All Americans Now." The Masai, a tribe in rural Kenya, sent us 14 cows, a gift regarded by their culture as sacred. Six years later, angry demonstrators trail our president wherever he travels, and it is headline news when he is actually cheered in Albania.
Six years ago, we vowed revenge on Osama bin Laden, the wealthy Saudi who masterminded the attacks. We would bring him in, said the president, "dead or alive." Six years later, bin Laden is still free, and the president has said he is not particularly concerned about that.
Do you remember?
The terrorist attacks of six years ago this week are sometimes compared to the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor 66 years ago this Dec. 7. That is, of course, a reference to the shock, disbelief and anger Americans of both eras felt.
But there is a telling difference between 12/7 and 9/11. From the 1941 attack, there was forged a sense of national mission and purpose. Feelings of shock, disbelief and anger became the building blocks of a consensus that we would do whatever, spend whatever and sacrifice whatever until victory was won. After the 2001 attacks, by contrast, we talked national mission and purpose, but it soon became apparent that it was only talk.
Those feelings of shock, disbelief and anger became instead the building blocks of a political machine that duped the nation into a war of choice that had nothing to do with the terrorist attacks, eroded American civil liberties under the guise of protecting American lives and branded as traitors those who said, "Hey, wait a minute."
Worst of all, it squandered the moment, threw away a historic chance to build a national — and international — consensus that could have marginalized the architects of terror, maybe even reshaped the world, more effectively than all the bombs and bullets used to date in Iraq.
This anniversary, then, laments not simply the loss of life, but of opportunity. And perhaps the worst thing is, one senses most Americans are like their president: We don't think about bin Laden that much these days. He is not front-of-mind anymore.
So it is worth pausing here to remember that just six years ago, we were attacked.
Six years ago, people leaped from flaming skyscrapers.
Six years ago, skyscrapers fell.
Six years ago, an airplane tore a hole in the Pentagon.
Six years ago, a hijacked plane crashed.
Six years ago, searing, airless shock was followed by resolve. Clear, cold, iron-fisted resolve.
Six years later, the shock is gone and it seems like the resolve is, too.
Do we remember? You couldn't prove it by me.
Miami Herald columnist Leonard Pitts Jr.'s column appears regularly on editorial pages of The Times. His e-mail address is: lpitts@herald.com
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2007-09-10 06:17 am (UTC)I remember that a gay guy saved one plane from smashing into another building, and how quickly the media buried that part of the story.
I remember how the suicide dudes were told to shave, because of America's prejudice against anyone with a beard. I remember the media burying that part of the story too, usually just as after a Gillette commercial came on. If you're clean cut, you can get away with murder. Literally.
Now, 6 years later and back on the air, we get listeners who finally agree with us. Why is Bin Lauden still out there?
Because if you kill the bad guy(s), the war is over.
It never was a war to find the bad guys. It was a war to benefit our corporations, and still is.
no subject
Date: 2007-09-10 06:53 am (UTC)We're running school "as usual" and letting the kids know they're in a safe place. One student asks me in the hall later that day, "why would they do that to us?"
This is a 9 year old.
I reply, "the United States is so huge and so powerful, and these people are so small and few in number, that this is how they felt they could force themselves to be heard."
I was currently re-reading George Orwell's "Animal Farm" and watched a perfectly orchestrated ballet based upon that book unfold from the White House.
Little did I know that within one year "Animal Farm" would have transmuted to "1984". But that's right where we are.
If you've never read Animal Farm as an adult, I recommend it. Osama was (and still is) Snowball.
Liberals have become "Goldstein" from 1984.
War is Peace.
We must fight them there so we don't fight them here.
Freedom is Slavery.
We must sacrifice our civil rights for security.
Ignorance is Strength.
We must unquestioningly and unwaiveringly support our nation's president.
no subject
Date: 2007-09-10 03:47 pm (UTC)Every Living Room is Room 101.
Date: 2007-09-11 03:03 pm (UTC)Not to be paranoid or anything, but I wonder if the FBI already has dossiers on us, just because we write political commentary that opposes the entrenched power.